What is the difference between a purifier and a clarifier?
A purifier removes water and solids from oil and has a water outlet. A clarifier removes only solids, has no water outlet and suits oil with very little water.
Updated 2026-11-02
Short answer
A purifier separates water and solids from oil and discharges the water continuously through its own outlet. A clarifier separates only solids from oil. It has no water outlet and no oil and water interface, and the small amount of water it removes collects in the sludge space with the solids.
In detail
Both are disc-stack centrifugal separators, and on many makes the same machine can be set up as either. The difference is in the bowl parts.
In a purifier, a water seal is made in the bowl before oil is fed in, and the bowl then holds an interface between the heavier water and the lighter oil. Clean oil leaves from the centre and separated water leaves over the gravity disc at the top of the bowl. The gravity disc bore decides where the interface sits, so it has to match the oil's density and temperature. With too large a bore the interface moves out, the seal breaks and oil is lost through the water outlet. With too small a bore, water carries over into the clean oil.
In a clarifier the gravity disc is replaced by a clarifier disc, a sealing ring that closes off the water outlet. No water seal is needed. The full disc stack works on the oil, and solids such as cat fines, rust and carbon are thrown outwards to the sludge space and removed at each discharge. With no interface to hold, a clarifier is generally better at removing fine solids than a purifier at the same throughput. Its weakness is water. If the feed carries much water, the sludge space fills quickly and water can pass out with the oil.
Modern self-cleaning separators have blurred the line. Systems such as Alfa Laval's ALCAP run without a gravity disc. A sensor in the clean oil outlet detects water, and the control unit removes it through a drain valve or a bowl discharge. One unit covers a wide range of densities, including heavy fuel up to 1010 kg/m3 at 15 C, beyond the limit of about 991 kg/m3 for a conventional purifier.
On ships with two or more fuel separators, older plants often ran a purifier followed by a clarifier in series. The purifier took out the water and the clarifier polished out the remaining fines. Some makers now recommend running the separators in parallel at a lower feed rate per unit, because a lower flow gives the oil more time in the bowl. Follow the maker's instructions for your installation.
Cat fines are the main reason this matters. They are hard particles of aluminium and silicon compounds left in residual fuel by the refinery's catalytic cracking process. They wear fuel pumps, fuel valves, piston rings and liners quickly. Engine makers commonly specify no more than about 15 mg/kg of aluminium plus silicon at the engine inlet. Whichever arrangement is used, the right feed temperature, typically about 98 C for heavy fuel, and a low enough throughput matter at least as much as the choice between purifier and clarifier mode.
Related Terms
Continue Reading
More Questions in Marine Machinery
Low fuel pump pressure is usually a blocked filter, air leak, open relief valve, wrong fuel temperature or worn pump. Check these before touching the set point.
Poor purifier separation usually comes from overfeeding, low feed temperature, the wrong gravity disc, a lost water seal or a dirty bowl. Check them in order.
A compressor that runs but won't fill the receiver usually has leaking valves. Next check the unloader, drains, leaks, cooling, intake filter and piston rings.
A swinging boiler water level usually means foaming, priming or shrink and swell, or a false reading from the feed control or gauge glass. Prove it first.
